1
Challenges Comments / Re: Challenge #892, NdSC #42
« on: Today at 04:11 PM »It is not an incorrect assumption.It is an incorrect assumption, you and Triad did not and still do not have the same view of what a swoosh is. To you it looks like an arch so you have the opinion that it isn't a swoosh, for Triad it is enough that the rope shoots to the right if even if it looks like it would be an arch on the last frame the rope is visible. (03:40.60 in the replay)
That picture, it's not a swoosh it's an arch!You yourself wrote earlier in this thread that what is and isn't a trick is a matter of opinion, so why are you stating it as a fact that it's not a swoosh?
It looks like an arch because the rope undergoes a frame of internal motion before being released.
I said if the only requirement to be a swoosh is to fire rope right then sure its a swoosh.In the context of this challenge that is what constitutes as a swoosh, here in this challenge that is in fact a swoosh.
I am not wrong about the angle you can see in the picture that the rope is going left from the middleThat isn't the angle we were discussing. We were discussing the angle of the rope on the frame after the last frame the rope is rendered (03:40.62 in the replay). You said that angle would be at best totally vertical, but it is actually sloped slightly to the right.
Though yes, I'll admit I temporary forgot about the pre-frame thing. Which is irrelevantIt's relevant to determine a correct result in the context of this challenge, where if the rope shoots to the right after release even if it looks like an arch it's considered a swoosh.