Cool that you played but now you need to play again
You played only on island maps.. Aladdin has played 2 matches already and still didn't remember the rule? You must play 2 x island, 2 x cave, 2 x island etc.
Continue from situation 1-1 and play 2 times on a cave map. If it goes to 5th round, then Aladdin wins 3-2.
Edit: kins must win both cave rounds or he loses. If either cave round ends in a draw, Aladdin wins. That's because after 2 cave rounds it's 2 x island again and Aladdin won those.