See.. sogeking just said his agrument in a mature fashion so don't bash him.
I think he has a point, the system is good but at the moment life is too easy for 4 playoff spots, and too hard for the other 4. But i don't think you should get rid of the the highest in overall stats making playoffs because they have put the work in to getting there. Also overtime the community will develope and it will be harder for flori to make playoffs. But at the moment i think sogeking does have a point that the tus system is great, but not for the current condition of the community as it is open to noobbashers and abusers.
I suggest three things to fix the issues sogeking has complained about..
- The playoffs are made up from top 6 of seasonal points, top 2 of overal.
- The playoffs selection stays the same, we see what happens with the added 50 games to reach them and a limit of 3/5 games per day vs same player (5 may be best?).
- Seeing as this has been tus's most active season and it could promise to see more activity in the future. The playoffs is selected of 16 players.. 12 seasonal, 4 overall. The mods have to be very strict on deadlines of playoff games getting done and whoever makes the least effort (like now) is booted from a round to get the po's finished faster
I think there are problems with all three of those suggestions and to be honest i think the second one is probably the best. Because i think its gonna be harder for the overall points candiates to play 50 games and avoid other players in the top 20. Also putting a max on the number of games vs same player per day will prevent noob bashing and abuse. Even if it does effect activity of tus, it will not effective it that badly as there are plenty of wormers asking for tus..
The first suggestion along may be abit exterme, 2 players at top of overall points could still find it easy to reach playoffs, and players who are under them may struggle to get into the seasonal points spots because of their high overall rating and not gaining that much.
The third suggestion could be awesome.. But its just a cause of can tus staff get and players finish and mod the playoffs with double the people inside them?
So heres a current example of who would make playoffs under these three different methods..
6 seasonal, 2 overall, 40 games still
- #1 Unique
- #2 Flori
- #3 Csongi
- #4 Gonzo
- #5 Weeman
- #6 Zippo
- #7 Juice
- #8 NaiL
Here little changes from the current selection. Ray is not encluded and instead Juice is. NaiL is 8th because of his seasonal points, not his overall. Sogeking is 4 games short of gaining 8th spot.
Current system, but with 50 games
- #1 Unique
- #2 Ray
- #3 Consgi
- #4 NaiL
- #5 Weeman
- #6 JackDaniels
- #7 Zippo
- #8 RoK
Quiet a different selection as Flori and Gonzo have not reached 50 games.
16 players, 40 games stills. 12 from seasonal, 4 overall
- #1 Unique
- #2 Flori
- #3 Consgi
- #4 Gonzo
- #5 Weeman
- #6 Ray
- #7 Zippo
- #8 NaiL
- #9 Juice
- #10 Phanton
- #11 allais
- #12 Uber
- #13 Dulek
- #14 Camperz
- #15 SacrificalLamb
- #16 RoK
A list of active players from the season, all with more than 50% winning ration. But makes it too easy to maybe reach the playoffs??
I guess that can give you an idea into which selection process could be best?