imo the post moderation is not necassary to make people following the forum rules, its just unnecassary work for the mods who need to approve the posts.
without the moderation step, muting would directly follow after a an warning.
i cant see any disadvantages for possible victims because until your posts are approved people are mostly already talking about something else.
this would maybe change the green dot to an serious warning instead of beeing an status symbol for bad asses.
in fact i would like to have system where u get muted for quite a long time after you received an warning and and still do the same things like before.
a direct mute hmm, is quite impossible imo, cant tell any examples which deserve this. (maybe if you post some real ugly stuff like making jokes about zippos death brother)
im excited about your opinions
I second this.
Quote from: Peja on September 12, 2011, 12:39 AM
in fact i would like to have system where u get muted for quite a long time after you received an warning and and still do the same things like before.
this kinda is running already , atleast in shoutbox
i got banned cos i said "zippo"(when MI said " the next one who write zippo , will be banned from shoubox) when zippo was in his best moment of trolling (ye , he deserved ppl make fun of him( not with stuff like that one about his brother tho )) for 2 weeks , and time after that, i got banned again cos i called sniper "cheater" and "fat" xD (which is completely true) i have been baned like 2 months or so , and im still banned
and if i get unbanned someday , ppl must be sure i wont change , im learning nothing , cos faggots like this 2 deserve to be humiliated
Respect is everything.
Quote from: Guaton on September 12, 2011, 04:14 AM
this kinda is running already , atleast in shoutbox
i got banned cos i said "zippo"(when MI said " the next one who write zippo , will be banned from shoubox) when zippo was in his best moment of trolling (ye , he deserved ppl make fun of him( not with stuff like that one about his brother tho )) for 2 weeks , and time after that, i got banned again cos i called sniper "cheater" and "fat" xD (which is completely true) i have been baned like 2 months or so , and im still banned
and if i get unbanned someday , ppl must be sure i wont change , im learning nothing , cos faggots like this 2 deserve to be humiliated
Wow I must be so unfair, poor Guaton :'(
If you need to humiliate these "faggots" do it on AG. These forums have seen enough of humiliations.
test to see if i can post: maybe since we vote on everything else.... when MI thinks someone deserves to be warned, moderated, muted, etc...
we have a special little vote... its like a court room, where we all are the jury!! haha now that would be so much fun...
Quote from: MonkeyIsland on September 12, 2011, 05:31 AM
Quote from: Guaton on September 12, 2011, 04:14 AM
this kinda is running already , atleast in shoutbox
i got banned cos i said "zippo"(when MI said " the next one who write zippo , will be banned from shoubox) when zippo was in his best moment of trolling (ye , he deserved ppl make fun of him( not with stuff like that one about his brother tho )) for 2 weeks , and time after that, i got banned again cos i called sniper "cheater" and "fat" xD (which is completely true) i have been baned like 2 months or so , and im still banned
and if i get unbanned someday , ppl must be sure i wont change , im learning nothing , cos faggots like this 2 deserve to be humiliated
Wow I must be so unfair, poor Guaton :'(
think whatever u want
Quote from: Guaton on September 12, 2011, 12:48 PM
Quote from: MonkeyIsland on September 12, 2011, 05:31 AM
Quote from: Guaton on September 12, 2011, 04:14 AM
this kinda is running already , atleast in shoutbox
i got banned cos i said "zippo"(when MI said " the next one who write zippo , will be banned from shoubox) when zippo was in his best moment of trolling (ye , he deserved ppl make fun of him( not with stuff like that one about his brother tho )) for 2 weeks , and time after that, i got banned again cos i called sniper "cheater" and "fat" xD (which is completely true) i have been baned like 2 months or so , and im still banned
and if i get unbanned someday , ppl must be sure i wont change , im learning nothing , cos faggots like this 2 deserve to be humiliated
Wow I must be so unfair, poor Guaton :'(
think whatever u want
No soup for you! NEXT!
(http://servingstrong.com/wp-content/uploads/SoupNazi1.jpg)
I know I went too far with what I said to nail, I didn't deserve to be "moderated" I should have been "muted" for a week or something.
I am a concerned, I mean, logically, they should have muted me because, only 2/3 posts I have wrote out of about 40-50 have been checked, why have disciplinary procedure that isn't followed through with?
It said, and still says: "You Are Currently Under Post Moderation - Your Post Will Appear After Approval"
For starters, wtf is with all the caps lol, anyway, I feel like I haven't been moderated at all, I have been muted, if they were actually moderating me properly my apology to nail would have been approved within 1 day, it's been almost 2 weeks, and still nothing.
I know MI is busy, but it is silly to make rules that are not followed, if you don't have the time to actually moderate someone, just mute them, cuz that's what you done anyway mate.
When someone is muted/banned etc I think they should still be able to post in their private forums of their clan/community.
However, whoever checked and approved my PO post, thank you very much :)
my opinion about this is to mute peja and guaton!!
Quote from: Komito on September 12, 2011, 08:50 PM
When someone is muted/banned etc I think they should still be able to post in their private forums of their clan/community.
Gonna have to disagree with you there. What's the point of mute/ban if there's hardly a consequence to it?
To be fair I think if you are "under moderation" and the mods are too busy to get around to approving your posts because they are dealing with the true purpose of this site then that is just 1 more reason to not get moderated in the first place.
It's essentially part of the punishment, why would mods make priority to approving posts of known spammers/trolls etc when they have cups / leagues / challenges and so on to moderate.
Time is precious and running sites like this is time consuming.
Don't get put under moderation is the best solution :D
hauhauahuahuahauha
i think the moderation works good... i enjoyed my stay there, and think mods did a good job while i was under moderation...
of course the posts will not be approved within a couple hours, maybe not even a day... they have better shit to do...
TUS FTW FOS4L
Quote from: DarkOne on September 13, 2011, 08:55 PM
Quote from: Komito on September 12, 2011, 08:50 PM
When someone is muted/banned etc I think they should still be able to post in their private forums of their clan/community.
Gonna have to disagree with you there. What's the point of mute/ban if there's hardly a consequence to it?
No one can see anyone elses private forums or ever will, it's still obviously a punishment not being able to do anything in the main part, you get me?
Quote from: avirex on September 14, 2011, 03:32 AM
i think the moderation works good... i enjoyed my stay there, and think mods did a good job while i was under moderation...
of course the posts will not be approved within a couple hours, maybe not even a day... they have better shit to do...
TUS FTW FOS4L
thats excatly my point, why should they have more work cause you acted like wrong?
i dont really think its more work.... MonkeyIsland reads all the forums either way, so its not any different... just the moderated posts he will have to approve... its more then likely no more then just clicking "accept" or whatever....
i dont think you should be able to post in your private forums though komo, thats pretty silly...
its like when your a kid, and your parents punish you.... they say no T.V. for a week...
think you should be able to watch TV in your "private" bedroom because its "obviously a punishment not being able to" watch TV in the living room? you get me? lololololol
Yeah funny that avi, the same people who don't believe in the death penelty, who believe in criminal restorative justice, who is ok with letting a man who murdered 10's upon 100's maybe even 1000's a chance to "better himself" yet, BAN KOMO FROM EVERYTHING CUZ HE SAID SOME BAD WORDS!!!!...
At least I apologised to nail, at least I realised what I done wrong, but you, pffft.
Yeah, whatever...
whoa, komo... where did that come from?? did you take your medication today???
apparently you are still a little bitter because monkeyisland moderated us both? i sure hope he does not ban us someday, as much as i may poke fun at you... it really would not be comical in any way if kami yourself over it :D
"omg monkey ban me??!?!?!??! real life f4!!!"
Well avi, we just can't resist it lol, it'll happen someday.