Quote from: ShyGuy on July 27, 2010, 11:38 PM
check out the thread avi made a few days ago... it has a replay of him and I playing w2roper... he also wrote down the crate stats... he got like 10 impossible crates as opposed to mine 5 or something, and the game was still very close because avi used some tactics... watch the replay or something :p
ok I watched the replay, but I can't say it was pretty. you both had quite a few mistakes and missed opportunities. since you guys really seem to think this replay proves something, I have to say that it actually doesn't. If you have a replay that isn't as messy as this one, I'd like to see it, but as for this one, I'll tell you why I don't like it.
I went through each turn and I tried to keep track of all the damage lost from mistakes and missed opportunities. I also awarded +damage when you guys attacked higher than the average 47 attack. what did I find?
well, in avi's post about the replay, he mentions at 8 minutes that although he had more impossible crates, he was winning 262-209. yes, that is all true, but tallying shyguy's mistakes, I had him at -328 in lost damage vs avi's -136 in lost damage. that's the real reason why avi was leading here.
avi also mentions at 12 minutes he had 'a wopping 9 crates that were impossible, and 1 questionable, and shy still only 2-2... yet the score was just about tied, me having 172, and shyguy having 174.' yet again shyguy's mistakes tallied him at -334 vs avi's -199.
avi ends by saying "by the end of the game i had 13 impossible, and 1 questionable.. and shy had 5 impossible and 2 questionable, it was not until i gave myself 20 FD second to last turn, and totally blew my last turn killing myself was the game over... there were plenty of cr8s on the map for me to retreive and hide, if i had not fallen there was plenty of possibility for me to have won... therefor shy was the better skilled player of this match, cr8s had absolutely nothing to do with the outcome."
until your last turn avi, shyguy had -357 in lost damage while you had only -220. I argue that shyguy was NOT the better skilled player of this match, and that cr8s DEFINITELY had something to do with the outcome of keeping shyguy ahead.
do you have a better replay I can check? =\