Challenges > Challenges

Challenge #175, TTRR Challenge Week 111

<< < (4/4)

Mablak:
Ah I thought I responded in this topic, here's what I said:

"Dulek, that's really not consistent with other finishes, there's never been any map where touching the letters directly didn't count as a finish. I mean that's the one non-ambiguous situation, direct contact with letters. I could imagine this being rejected if it said 'Finish' and was pointing somewhere else, but that's not the case. Also, Statik's run doesn't touch the top of the finish, it hits the side of the letters, I don't see why you would want to treat it like a block when there is no block."

And Dulek said:

"There's a difference between your and Statik's turn. If the finish was a continous line, Statik would have landed on it and you still would have slipped of it (touched the side of it). I know on maps like this (or any other Eminef's/AZ01's like this) you don't need to land on the letters and you can just touch them from their side but on this map the finish is 'floating' and I count it somewhat different.

Pink line represents where the finish should be in my opinion.


But sure, I'm willing to change my decision, I would like to listen to other ppl's opinion. :)"

I still don't get why you're drawing a line over the top, most people would agree that touching letters directly generally counts. I touched the side of a letter, Statik touched the side of a letter, I see no difference.

deejay:
Ive always counted a finish as either touching back wall/touching the letters atall. Mablaks run was awesome, dont cut him out just because of him sliding off the finish.

deejay

Dulek:
Done.

Mablak:
Okay, thanks for reconsidering.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[*] Previous page