If you look at the statistics, if any of those players I list went and took a season as seriously as Random has done then I don't think random would have as many gold medals.
Im not denying their skill and achievements, I would say they are the best allrounders, but I am merely stating that there have not been enough allrounders who have tried to challange them. If there was I think their records would be different. At the moment Almog is climbing to a near Random level IMO, he is consistently making the playoffs. If Franz, Diana, Artic, Dibz, Dulek, Crash etc etc were all consistently making the playoffs then I think the statistics that we see in tus would be way different. Some of the other great allrounders don't even bother playing tus anymore as they have already reached elite rank or won tus once. Csongi told me he doesnt have much motivation for it after winning a season, that happened to be one where Random didn't qualify. If i was him i'd want to keep on making playoffs to try and knock Random out.
Rather than asking for some best allrounder show down, I think more of the top allrounders should prove that they have what it takes to replicate a record like Random, as MI pointed out. Madden is more consistent than Random because the only season where he wanted to reach playoffs and was active enough, he knocked out Random.
Look at Artic, he beat Random in final and has another final against him. What if Artic wins this?
Random doesn't come up against the same 8 guys in the playoffs each season, which could easly be the case if other top players were more motivated and active.
Mablak hasn't even played tus. He needs to prove himself. I could imagine he wouldn't put a flawless streak together. Think of the level of skill in hysteria that has developed! I've never seen mab play hysteria but all that turn time in inter he is used to may effect those 1 second moves.