Karma destiny at your hand

[DENnis]

Hmm you didn't put my idea to the options, that you have to reply and write down WHY you want to smite. Same way like you have to explain why you want to upload a freewin.

Without a good reason you shouldn't be able to smite!

Please think about my idea, too. Remove the smitesystem at all wouldn't be necessary then.

MI, this is very nice, that you always let the whole community decide! + For all your nice work and that you keep improving the tussite always.

[Peja]

Hmm you didn't put my idea to the options, that you have to reply and write down WHY you want to smite. Same way like you have to explain why you want to upload a freewin.

Without a good reason you shouldn't be able to smite!

Please think about my idea, too. Remove the smitesystem at all wouldn't be necessary then.

MI, this is very nice, that you always let the whole community decide! + For all your nice work and that you keep improving the tussite always.

i smite you cause your gay,
i smite you because your retard
i smite you because you look like roseanne,
..........


sorry DEN,   your option would create stuff like this

[Desetroyah]

sorry DEN,   your option would create stuff like this

nah, you would create stuff like this   dont get me wrong, being/looking gay in pics is pretty bad but if I knew who the hell's Roseanne I might've agreed with you

[ANO]

f@#! is this topic?

[philie]

dunno ano, some nerd shit.

[DumbBongChow]

Well... This topic is made by MonkeyIsland himself, so you guys have to kind of watch out what you say. -_-;

I actually believe this topic is a bad idea though. The topic and poll still may still not work if even majority of people are willing to make sound bias free judgement. I believe MonkeyIsland made this post quickly because HE IS FREAKIN TIRED OF KARMA ARGUMENTS ESPECIALLY ALL THE KRAZY SMACK TALKS.

Hmm you didn't put my idea to the options, that you have to reply and write down WHY you want to smite. Same way like you have to explain why you want to upload a freewin.

Without a good reason you shouldn't be able to smite!

Please think about my idea, too. Remove the smitesystem at all wouldn't be necessary then.

MI, this is very nice, that you always let the whole community decide! + For all your nice work and that you keep improving the tussite always. a

i smite you cause your gay,
i smite you because your retard
i smite you because you look like roseanne,
..........


sorry DEN,   your option would create stuff like this

Peja, I disagree actually. I think moderator is smart enough which are BS reasons or not, but it will be hard for moderators to moderate on this. The problem with Dennis's idea is that ppl may come up with good reasoning while the reason is actually a lie. How will moderator supposed to know whether the reason for smite and applaud is a lie or not.

Here is what DoGGy was referring to:

This system should have never exsisted, it never did anything good, never made any sense, never told us any new information. The part of this community with the higher intelligence - which part should be running this league and everything - realized that. The stupid part - excuse me for those who have something for this system and are on the brighter side for sure - wants to keep it, because they are stupid.

There should be no poll for such shit, MonkeyIsland, you should just go ahead and make decisions like this yourself... I never understood this unnatural democracy, most of the times you are giving the decisions to people who should obviously not decide.

There's no question by creating karma system, it have caused lot of problem.  Ray's quote, "The poll is going to do show us that there are more stupid people than intelligent people", assumes that anyone who goes for karma system is stupid which is not true. (More has to do with bias and favoritism.) I think karma system is rather interesting system, but the current system is rather flawed. Check my other post and NaiL from another karma topic for more info on why it's flawed. MonkeyIsland, this poll is not a good idea as we're relying on majority vote to makes decision. Some people just don't make a good decision when it comes to stuff like this, and I haven't even voted it yet because I think there are two effectively solutions to this problem:  Remove karma entirely or fix flaws for the karma system. I prefer second solution, but it takes more work for the moderators. YOU SHOULD DECIDE YOURSELF as Ray said, but I do believe your final decision should decide largely based only on the good arguments we've had over karma system and your owning rational reasoning. Then make a topic why you make a decision with various reasons stated. Hope that helped everyone.

[SPW]

If karma system went off, some people will suicide I guess cause their favourite playing-tool is f@#!ed off then. Now smite me for this, I dont care now, in the past and in the future about it at all.

To proove real sportmanship you need years and there are a lot of people which stand for it. Who cares a ridicoulus karma system. Useless at all. ;d

stay or gay ladies.  

[DumbBongChow]

If karma system went off, some people will suicide I guess cause their favourite playing-tool is f@#!ed off then. Now smite me for this, I dont care now, in the past and in the future about it at all.

To proove real sportmanship you need years and there are a lot of people which stand for it. Who cares a ridicoulus karma system. Useless at all. ;d

stay or gay ladies.  

As cynical as he's saying it, it's actually somewhat true.

[Prankster]

Hmm you didn't put my idea to the options, that you have to reply and write down WHY you want to smite. Same way like you have to explain why you want to upload a freewin.
Without a good reason you shouldn't be able to smite!

Oh, man, and who will decide if your reason is a good reason? [ * ] Democracy is not the ultimate answer to everything.. (It's 42.)

*For those who might lost my train of thought: I suppose that the most likely answer would be something like that mods would do the censor. >> But I don't think they could handle that, when moderated people's posts are too much already. >> So the other option could be a vote about the reason. >> That's just nonsense.

[nino]

kiros where are u? huahauha 

[Farco/Ghost]

I guess this Karma thing can show how people that are immature and mature they are, I think. Bad reputations can also mean like that, I guess.. D:

[avirex]

it really is ridiculous how much you guys care...  to the point where you type huge essay style posts about the flaw, pros, and cons.... its so silly, did you ever stop to think maybe thats why the karma system was abused in the past? because you guys care so much.... sure, maybe it was immature to abuse the system, but i would say it was equally if not more immature to care.

[Ramone]

avi, how the heck can't U realize after all these time how much your posts are totally paradoxal and contradictory? And they sounds like you're speaking to yourself all the time.. But U never hear yourself.

[avirex]

maybe all these time you will make sense, so i can understand what in the hell your talking about.

[Kaleu]

+1 Ramone.
Imo he don't care for anything, just want to troll around tus and get enough number of posts.