Wow, you guys even make a thread about fair play about yourselves? No wonder I'm so inactive in TUS at the moment.
It's good to see a community like this gets opened, because I'm always up for fair play. I'd rather lose an exciting and fun game than win a boring game, but unfortunately when I look at how this thread derailed so quickly, I'd say this community has a long way to go.
Impo, vent your problems with Professor elsewhere, please. This thread is not about you and not about Professor.
Statik, the idea is good, but you kind of go against your own idea when you focus your attention to the negatives (your warning list) - something I might add is a reason why this thread is derailing.