Quote from: darKz on May 23, 2014, 10:44 AM
Buddhists are atheists by definition, yet they believe in a lot of things like empathy and forgiving. Imo they're the prime example of why the belief in a supernatural being is not at all necessary to be(come) a good and caring person.
Buddhism is a great philosophy for that reason. Not a religion by definition, but in my estimation is a guiding force for the greater good. Also, I apologize for not clarifying my beliefs earlier, but Darkz post made me remember, I have a strong belief that people live a spiritual life to fulfill their potential, whatever that may be. I believe that people that live a life not dedicated to self are destined for enlightenment in the afterlife. I think I made religion my vessel for argument because the two are obviously interrelated and it was convenient to use the same vernacular.
Quote from: Aerox on May 23, 2014, 07:09 AM
Social evil? I already asked if you were trying to balance the good vs the bad of religion for the overall of society. You didn't answer. Speaking for myself, I'd never go there. However, there's lots of bad coming from religion. People live happier with faith sure. There are studies revealing that being a slave also offers comfort to one's live.
Sure, there's money laundering, there's food for the poor and there's erm... spiritual guidance... sure that's good for society. But what about all the actual documented evils religion has brought, and brings by nature?
I'm not trying to balance anything, but if I was omnipotent, I would.
There is no documented evil that religion (as a discipline) brings by nature. I challenge you to show me this 'documentation.'
Quote from: Aerox on May 23, 2014, 07:09 AM
Is it because us humans got religion all wrong? Is religion good but our intepretation of it leads us to do bad things because we're bad but religion isn't? I really don't get why we're the crazys because we see things for what they are? What are we missing? A revelation?
Good questions. I believe that human beings inherently mess up religion as well as pretty much everything else. We are a sloppy, self-involved, corrupted species, myself included. Religion is inherently good, selfish interpretation of spirituality is bad. A bad interpretation would be pontiff worship in the Catholic church. A single man should never be elevated by religion like he is. There is much wrong with that religion, I renounced it many years ago. The Catholic church does a lot of good, but is utterly corrupt.
Quote from: Mablak on May 23, 2014, 07:54 AM
As for inherent positives, no one has demonstrated that there are in fact positives that religion brings, that secularism doesn't also bring (on the whole). I did not demonize religious motives in any way; I may think the religious who do good are sometimes doing so for the wrong reasons, but I wouldn't suggest they're not doing good when they perform acts that genuinely help people.
No one has demonstrated the positives secularism brings eclipse those of religion, as a whole. See what I did there? Both are anomalous statements.
How can someone do good for the wrong reasons? People always do good for the right reasons in my estimation, because the good one puts forth is always more valuable than whatever ideation led them to their decision to do good.
Quote from: Mablak on May 23, 2014, 07:54 AM
You seem to have assumed I'm saying that religion reduces empathy, giving, etc, when I'm merely arguing there's no evidence that it boosts these things above what the non-religious do.
Then you don't realize that your pervasive and running point is that religion creates more evil than it does good. It is written all up and down your posts.
As far as your cited source, the church gave 4.7b of it's revenue to charity, not 4.7%, but it looks to be about 4.7% anyways so that is kosher regardless. Catholic charities, however, in not represented in your graph and is what I was referencing. Catholic charities gives far more than 4.7% of their gross; your graph shows the Church giving 4.7% to charity, most of that which goes to Catholic charities.

Catholic church spending is not the same as the charitable foundation that they have established. Catholic charities is a wonderful organization, but represents a small part of the gross revenue of the church.