Yeah the ones who are voting like that are the ones who like to smite every1 for stupidty, keep it like that MI, keep feeding the cowardness.

and at least one "No" vote was accident;X

I have voted for 3rd option (Yes, and allow posts to be rated instead)! ^^

same here.

Edit: U know like facebook, ppl make comments or put what they are thinking and we the ppl who are his friends can either comment the state or put "I like it", many ppl have asked on fb to put the option "I don't like" like this page fb is a community only difference is that this also a league of a internet playing community,  I would like that the system was like fb so we can comment the posts say if we like or if we hate it.

Quote from: devilage on April 26, 2010, 06:08 PM
Yeah the ones who are voting like that are the ones who like to smite every1 for stupidty, keep it like that MI, keep feeding the cowardness.

I've voted no, and I'm not a coward and I do not spend my time to smite people.
Actually, I've suggested a way to enable people from smitting  the same one everyday.
I'm sorry for the one concerned but people with a so low karma deserve it for some reason as for people with high karma.

Quote from: zippeurfou on April 26, 2010, 06:21 PM

I've voted no, and I'm not a coward and I do not spend my time to smite people.

[/quote]


OH right fada but... how do I know that? lol


Edit: u suggested more than one smitte per day so the balance of posibilities that u are smitting for no reason are against u

Because there's no one I hate in this community, so I've no reason to waste my time doing that.

Well anyway it's a bit out of the topic, sorry.

The topic is karma and we're talking bout that so we are still on the topic.

i voted no and i cant even remember the last time i smited some1(prolly the weed) i usually just applaud for good ideas and sportsmanship

yeah same here but it'sstill annon.

Quote from: MonkeyIsland on April 23, 2010, 07:05 PM
I would. But look at the poll in this topic.

Well its actually quite even if you consider both of the "no" options together.

I really think it needs to go, it creats an uneasy atmosphere, paranoia, people smiting people because they dont like them and not for contributions they may or may not have made.

There are lots of people on here who have negative karma (not mega low karma), but low karma still, when they do not deserve it. It creates a sort of unessecary heirachy and as dev said, promotes an anonymous, paranoid, bitchy atmosphere.

Get rid of it please! Everyone knows who's who, theres no need for it especially when all it does it promote negativity. I can go into a lot more detail as to why it does more bad than good...

 Agreed.

Quote from: NAiL on April 26, 2010, 07:31 PM
Well its actually quite even if you consider both of the "no" options together.

45% vs 55% is not that even, though. I'm sure some people would've voted differently if they had the option "No, but a few minor changes are needed".
The "anonymous, paranoid, bitchy atmosphere" (at least I think so) is not created by the karma system.
Plenty of sites that don't have the karma system have that very same atmosphere.

Right now:

146 members have positive karma.
80 members have negative karma.
950 members have zero.

I'm not talking about stadistics, I'm talking about a community that has an anonymous way to point the comments of the ppl, and that's what I don't like ppl can make a judgement of ur post or just do it to try to annoy or denigrate, it's not a big deal since this is a game, but even on games things shouldn't be secrects in a good way or in a bad way.